7.2.05

Odds/Ends

I've added composer Judith Lang Zaimont's new blog to the blogroll. By sheer coincidence, I heard the performance of her Growler she refers to in her first post. It was one of the better pieces on the program. I share her concern about the the programming of the FSU Festival, but it's always been that way--safe and regional.

* * * * *

Alex Ross has linked to the text of his keynote speech at the Chamber Music America National Conference. As always, he has a lot of interesting and thought-provoking things to say. This sentence struck me as shedding a particular kind of light on one important difference between concert-notational music and other kinds:

I can’t honestly say that Beethoven’s C-sharp minor Quartet is by any meaningful measure “better” than, say, Duke Ellington’s Come Sunday as sung by Mahalia Jackson.

I'm not saying that the difference here is a quantitative "better-or-worse" kind of difference, but rather a qualitative "nature of the beast" difference.

3 comments:

  1. The difference is that the reference is to a particular performance of the Ellington, and the reference to Beethoven is to the work. Again, I think that's a different kind of artifact, not better or worse, but different.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Cool! I got to know Judith when I taught at Minnesota. We had adjacent offices, with the lovely view of the Mississippi. Sigh.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks, Alex.

    I think these issues are both complex, in that there are a lot of moving definitional parts and overlapping traits between and amongst genres, and simple, because there are things we all "know" about music, but have trouble pinning them down verbally.

    ReplyDelete